By Scott Barzilla

Adam Ant was one of the many artist in the 1980s to produce a one hit wonder. He has spent the past two decades coasting on that one hit and getting in trouble with the law. That one hit was called “Goody Two Shoes” and had the memorable line, “don’t drink, don’t smoke, what do you do?’ While that exact line cannot be applied to Ed Wade and the Astros, the sentiment is the same. They don’t hit. They don’t pitch. They don’t field. They don’t run the bases particularly well. So, what exactly do they do?

The Astros are unique in a lot of ways in the analysis series. They are the only bottom half payroll team to be significantly below par in analysis. They are also the only team in baseball not to rank in the top twenty in any particular category. Ownership is supposed to be turning over soon, but that keeps getting delayed. Watching that delay for Ed Wade must be like watching the grim reaper try to negotiate the lock on the door. You know its only a matter of time.

Key Statistics

Team Payroll: 70.7 (20th)

Lineup: 26.8

Rotation: 21.1

Bullpen: 22.7

Composite Ranking: 23.5

Analysis Score: -3.5


To be perfectly fair to Wade, the biggest mistake the Houston Astros made was paying Carlos Lee 100 million dollars over six years. That was on Tim Purpura and Drayton McLane. It was also on those two when they decided to let the farm system turn into crap. Ed Wade has slowly but surely put in more talent into the farm system, but five years later they still rank in the bottom five according to most sources.

The problem in the lineup is easy to see. When Jason Castro went on the shelf, no one in the lineup remained who walked in even ten percent of his plate appearances. It was almost as if patience was the bubonic plague and free swinging was the cure. Add to that zero power outside of Carlos Lee and Hunter Pence and a helping of lack of speed (outside of Michael Bourn) and you had the makings of an absolutely crappy offense. If one were to draw up a blueprint on how not to create runs they would go to Ed Wade to do the drawings.


The rotation is better simply because Wandy Rodriguez and Bud Norris are there to make sure things don’t go completely off the tracks. However, Brett Myers and J.A. Happ are a study in inattention to the facts of batting average on balls in play (BABIP). Brett Myers had a 2010 season that screamed “CAREER YEAR, CAREER YEAR, CAREER YEAR!”, but Wade ignored that and decided that he had somehow turned a corner. His value was never higher and teams were even offering Grade A prospects for him. Wade wasn’t having any of that. Instead, Myers was signed to an extension that was an overpay the minute Myers signed it.

As for Happ, that was screw up in reverse. Happ was pitching over his head in Philadelphia, so instead of insisting on another good prospect, Wade wanted Happ. Happ continued to pitch well last season, so Wade felt vindicated. 2011 has been a disaster for Happ in a fall from grace that everyone but the Astros’ front office saw coming. Yet, these are foils that happen to an organization that doesn’t pay attention to numbers. They insist that they do, but do we believe their words or our lying eyes?


Ed Wade started a series of snark that hasn’t stopped when he inked Brandon Lyon to a three year 15 million dollar contract. Heck, year one of the deal was well worth the money when Lyon took over as the closer. Still, Lyon is another study in the stability of certain statistics. His Fielding independent pitching (FIP) numbers over the past five seasons (not counting 2011) read like this: 4.08, 3.44, 3.84, 4.06, 3.34. That is remarkably consistent and not the kind of numbers where you throw 15 million dollars around.

Lyon went down with an elbow injury midway through the season and it actually returned the Astros to the one strength Ed Wade possess. He is good at building a bullpen on the cheap. Mark Melancon, Wilton Lopez, Sergio Escalona, and Fernando Rodriguez combined to give the Astros a decent group of relievers. The trick is in realizing that you probably won’t be able to count on any of them long-term.

Response to Crisis

I’ve tried to avoid being snarky and have probably failed. So, I’ll try to provide some balance. Ed Wade did a credible job of trading three regulars for prospects. He also did a good job of recognizing he wasn’t going to get good value for Wandy Rodriguez right now. Out of the prospects gained, Jonathan Singleton and Jarred Cosart have the most promise. However, some like Henry Sosa, Jordan Schafer, and Juan Abreu are paying some dividends this year.

The only really questionable trade was the one involving Michael Bourn. He did not get any high profile prospects for the best leadoff hitter in the National League. He did get a couple of end of the rotation prospects in Paul Clemens and Brett Oberholtzer to accompany Schafer and Abreu. Abreu should end up being a middle reliever at the very least. Schafer should be the everyday centerfielder next year. Oberholtzer and Clemens both pitched well at Corpus Christi after the trade and should be promoted to AAA Oklahoma City next year.

Analysis Score: -3.5 (21st)

Final Analysis

There is no way Ed Wade ranks as high as this. He is the only GM of a bottom half team to have an analysis score significantly below zero. Most have scores well in the positive range. Moreover, you would think he would have a ranking in one of the three key areas higher than 21st based on luck alone. In essence, you have to try to be this bad.

Whether he will claim the bottom spot or not remains to be seen. Based on the results at the big league level (97 losses and counting) and the minor league level (lowest collective winning percentage in baseball) you would be hard pressed not to tab him for number 30.

Scott Barzilla

Scott Barzilla is the editor in chief at He is also the author of four books, including The Hall of Fame Index. The Hall of Fame Index was nominated for the Sporting News Award for statistical innovation in 2011.

More Posts - Twitter

Filed under: Central, NL, SABR

Tagged with: ,

Readers Comments (0)